PGF NEWS



e-Newsletter

I. Gender

II. Democracy Watch

III. Governance at Large

IV.Geo-Political Dynamics

Vol - II Edition - XI
February, 2008

Download: PDF Version
(Printable)


Gender

Women’s Day

Pakistani Women’s Day Observed

The 25th anniversary of Pakistani Women’s Day was commemorated on February 12 with a demand for amendments to laws discriminating against women. The day was observed to commemorate the infamous incident of police brutality at the Lahore High Court in 1983 in which women participating in a peaceful demonstration and exercising their rights to public assembly, protest and free speech against the draft Qanoon-e-Shahadat (Law of Evidence) were tear-gassed, baton-charged and dozens of them were arrested.

Benazir’s killing condemned: The Women’s Action Forum (WAF) strongly condemned the murder of Benazir Bhutto on the occasion. The forum said that Benazir was an icon of democratic values and possessed unparalleled leadership qualities. The forum said, “Benazir’s valuable contribution to Pakistani politics would never be forgotten.” Talking on the occasion, WAF founding member Begum Shahnaz Wazir Ali on behalf of all the forum’s women called for amendments in legislations discriminating women. She said, “Although many of the terrible laws have been removed or amended, still many exist that need to be dislodged.”

Paintings exhibition: Earlier, 20 artists including Abbas Shah, Afshan Shoaib, Amna Hashmi, Anjum Ayub, Arjumand Faisal, Altaf Ahmed, Adeela Aasia, AI Qureshi, Humera, Munaf Khan, Nahid Raza, N H Kazmi, Riffat Khattak, Samina Arjumand, Tabassum Rizvi, Tasneem Abbass, Tariq Kakar, Natalia Boichenco, Zaira A Zaka and Zia Zaidi displayed their paintings at an exhibition at the Nomad Art Gallery. The artists portrayed women’s difficulties and the undue social restrictions placed on them. Afshan Shoaib in her painting titled ‘Red Beads’ beautifully depicted the country’s political situation. The painting depicts a woman wearing a red beads garland and mourning the deteriorating law and order situation that has claimed thousands of lives including Benazir Bhutto.

Meanwhile, Rozan in collaboration with the Society for the Advancement of Community Health, Education and Training (SACHET), Poda and the Strengthening Participatory Organisation (SPO), organized National Women’s Day at the National Art Gallery (NAG). The participants of the event also called for amendments in the Hudood Ordinance and to remove lapses in the Women’s Protection Bill (WPB). Women from the quake-affected areas also depicted their works in a Women’s Art Mela.

Radio series: On this occasion, Uks in collaboration with the British High Commission (BHC) also launched a 16-programme radio series titled ‘Hamari Tarraqui, Hamaray Masael’ (our development, our problems). The series is based on women’s issues including gender equality and women’s rights. “Far away there in the sunshine are my highest aspirations. I may not reach them, but I can look up and see their beauty, believe in them and try to follow where they lead,” Sofia Shahid quoted Louise May Alcott while addressing the launching ceremony of the programme. She said the radio producers’ six-member team had travelled to Jafferabad, Naseerabad, Muslim Bagh, Sukkur, Dadu, Jaccobabad, Karachi, Meerwala, Jatoi, Karawali, Lodhran, Rullanwali, Abbotabad, Haripur, Hayatabad and Risalpur. The radio producers including Maria Mushtaq, Aisha Amir, Rafia Arshad, Saadia Haq and Rukhsana Murtaza searched for talent and recorded stories about women’s issues. National Commission of Status of Women (NCSW) Chairperson Dr Arifa Sayeda Zehra said there was only physical difference between a man and a woman, adding that women had courage, bravery and spirit equal to that of men. She said that it is the lack of courage in men that resists acceptance of women as equals to them. BHC representative Mathew Foreman said the story telling method was an important tool to spread the message. Executive Producer Tasneem Ahmer said they had tried to depict old stories in new ways. She further said that we have tried to highlight the positive aspects of the lives of successful women that would encourage other women to contribute.

Women & Politics

LHC Seeks Legality of Quota for Women

Lahore High Court Chief Justice Sayed Zahid Hussain on February 29 asked a petitioner who had challenged the provision of reserving seats for women in the national and provincial assemblies to submit on record what the original 1973 Constitution said regarding quota for women in the assemblies. Petitioner Tariq Aziz said there were 60 reserved seats for women in the National Assembly and 128 in four Provincial Assemblies. He said that 12 women had been elected directly to the previous National Assembly. He said that so far elections on the reserved seats had been made on the basis of kinship and influence and not on political considerations. He further said that according to the Article 25 of the Constitution there should be no discrimination on the basis of gender. He added that the government had to bear a burden of Rs1,006 million on election to the reserved seats and it paid Rs1,760,000,000 as salary and allowances to women elected on such seats. Instead of election on the basis of gender, technocrats from different walks of life should be brought into the legislature to make the process of legislation more meaningful. He said that in the Shereen Masood case it was said that women should be given admission to medical colleges on merit and not on quota basis. A five-member bench of the Supreme Court had done away with the quota system in medical collages in accordance with the Article 25 of the Constitution. Appearing on behalf of the Federal Government, the deputy attorney-general said the quota could not be challenged because it had been added to the Constitution through the 17th Amendment. The Chief Justice put off the hearing till next week.

Women’s Empowerment

Plan to induct more Women in Ministry

Caretaker Minister for Women Development Barrister Shahida Jamil said on February 26 that the Government plans to induct more women in the Ministry of Women Development (MoWD). She said that the process would be slow yet the objective is to bring in women at the decision-making level. She further said that the aim is not to have an all-women ministry but we would try to create gender balance.

The MoWD has always been criticized for having low representation of women among its folds especially at the top levels. The NGO representatives have highlighted the issue on several occasions. They have also taken note of the fact that male officials represent the Ministry and the country at most international forums. Interestingly, the office of ex-Minister for Women and Development Sumaira Malik had no female employee. There are about 21 people employed at the officer-level in the main administrative structure of MoWD. Among them only four are women including the Minister herself. Men head all the three departments – development, gender equality and administration. The UN CEDAW expert committee in Paragraph 32 of its concluding comments presented in response to Pakistan’s combined initial, second and third periodic report has shown concern over continuing low representation of women in the government services.

Women & HR

UN Launches Campaign to Fight Violence against Women

The United Nations launched a seven-year campaign to intensify its action to end violence against females on February 25. An announcement from the world body said that at least one out of every three women in the world is likely to be beaten, coerced into sex or otherwise abused in her lifetime, according to its estimates. One in five women will become a victim of rape or attempted rape, it says, adding that trafficking, sexual harassment, female genital mutilation, dowry murder, honour killings and female infanticide are other widespread aspects of the problem. The campaign will aim to mobilise public opinion to ensure that policy makers at the highest level work to prevent and eradicate violence against women. A key target will be to secure political will and increased resources from governments, international institutions, UN entities, the private sector and other donors for policies and programmes to deal with the problem. The UN secretary general is calling on world leaders, men and women, to lead national campaigns to end violence against women. Running from 2008 to 2015 to coincide with the target date of the Millennium Development Goals.

Girls Sold by Parents for Domestic Labour in Nepal

According to NYOF, there are over 20,000 indentured domestic workers, also known as 'Kamlari'. The 'Kamlari' system originated nearly 50 years ago when poor families belonging to the Tharu community, an indigenous ethnic group in southern Nepal's Terai region, provided daughters as domestic servants in exchange for cash. The practice is still prevalent and activists have started to call it "internal trafficking" of girls who are literally sold off by their parents with the help of local middlemen. The young Tharu girls, aged 6-10, are taken mainly from the districts of Dang, Bardiya, Kanchanpur, Kailali and Banke, all about 600km west of the capital. Most of the girls are brought to households in Nepal's cities and towns where employers include politicians, bureaucrats, local NGO workers, teachers, journalists, human rights activists, teachers and government officials, according to NYOF. In the last eight years, NYOF and FNC have helped to rescue over 4,000 girls, all whom have now joined schools or informal education programmes.

Abused: Besides the labour exploitation, the girls also suffer from sexual abuse, rape, physical torture, starvation and neglect of education, and there are also many cases of the girls being trafficked for prostitution both in Nepal and to India, according to FNC. In addition, many girls also disappear once they are purchased by the middlemen. "It's difficult to rescue most of these young girls as their whereabouts are mostly unknown and most of the time the parents do not cooperate," said Man Bahadur Chettri from FNC. He explained that NYOF and FNC have filed court cases against the agents and the parents to successfully get them to cooperate. Nepal has laws against employing children under 16 but they are yet to be strongly implemented, said NYOF's Paneru.

Saudi Women face Systematic Discrimination: UN Report

According to a UN Report, women in Saudi Arabia are the victims of systematic and pervasive discrimination across all aspects of social life, a United Nations report said on 1 February.

The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women urged the Saudi government to take concrete steps to enforce gender equality and end violence against women. The committee overseas the application of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), a UN treaty regarded as a global bill of rights for women. The Committee said in its report that neither the Constitution nor other legislation embodies the principle of equality between women and men. Saudi Arabia is governed by Wahabism, a strict interpretation of Islam that -- in the name of Sharia law -- imposes almost complete separation of the sexes. As such, it is illegal for a woman to be in the company of a man who is not in her immediate family. Women suffer from domestic violence, poor healthcare provision and high levels of illiteracy, the committee said in its report. They are also shackled by the obligation to have a male "tutor" or guardian to accompany them for many daily tasks. The report said that the concept of male guardianship contributes to the prevalence of a patriarchal ideology with stereotypes and the persistence of deep-rooted cultural norms that discriminate against women. It added that the level of representation of women in public and political life, at the local, national, and international levels and in particular in decision-making positions, is very low. The committee also expressed concern about female domestic migrant workers in the kingdom, who are vulnerable to economic and sexual exploitation and do not have ready access to the law. Earlier this month, a Saudi delegation told a meeting of the committee in Geneva that Saudi society is still largely a tribal society and changes in mentality allowing new ideas to be accepted takes time.

Report on Violence against Women by CCHD

Out of a total seven categories of violence against women, 901 cases of murder of women in Punjab were recorded during the year 2007, reportedly the highest as stated in a press conference by the Citizen's Commission for Human Development. While talking to reporters at the Press Club here on February 28, Director CCHD Farah Saleh said the annual report on VAW was compiled by CCHD based on monitoring of eight national dailies, adding that murder was the most common form of violence against women in Punjab in the year 2007. She maintained that the CCHD found that inadequate and discriminatory legal framework was the only hurdle for the victims seeking redress.It was told during the briefing that in 2007 out of 901 women murder cases in Punjab, only 657 cases were registered with the police with only 122 accused arrested. Out of the total number, only 565 women were married and 336 single, whereas close relatives had killed 747 women and unknown persons murdered 154. The second most common form of VAW reported in 2007 in Punjab was kidnapping. A total of 688 women were kidnapped in the year 2007 from the province, out of which only 449 cases were registered with the police and 49 accused arrested. The data further showed that 500 women committed suicide in 2007 (Punjab) out of which 263 were married women and 237 single. A total of 457 women were raped but only 295 cases were registered with the police. Amazingly 293 women were raped by close family members and 164 by unknown persons, servants or neighbours. It was further maintained that out of the total 317 cases of physical torture and harassment in Punjab in 2007, the number of cases reported in the newspapers were 205. About 132 cases were registered with the police. Moreover, 230 women were physically tortured whereas, 87 women were sexually harassed and 100 women burnt deliberately in Punjab in 2007 over petty issues. Out of the total, 47 cases were registered with the police, but only three accused were arrested. In them, 63 were married and 37 unmarried women were burnt. Out of the total 74 domestic violence cases, only 36 were registered with the police and 11 accused were arrested. In them, some 50 were married women and 24 unmarried.

Back to top

 


Democracy Watch

ECP News

By-Polls on Vacant Seats in April

The by-polls would be held on nearly two dozen seats, including nine of National Assembly constituencies, sometimes in April this year with two leading parties all set to bag most of them. The polls were postponed on four National Assembly and eight provincial assemblies’ seats, but there are a number of mainstream politicians who won more than one seats in the February 18 contest. Besides pending decision of several winners whether to sit in Centre or their respective provinces after they won at both levels, the polls would be organized on at least nine National Assembly constituencies as five successful are to vacate after they won from more than one seat. PML-N Qaid Mian Nawaz Sharif may prefer to contest from the Lahore Constituency (NA-119) where the election was postponed though his Party fellows are going to vacate four seats, including from Sheikhupura and Rawalpindi. Neither PPP nor PML-Q could manage to obtain even a single National Assembly seats from Sheikhupura whereas margin-wise the Rawalpindi constituencies in the hands of PML-N. Winners are more comfortable for Nawaz to contest once he gets nod of election authorities for taking part in the polls. Besides eight of the provincial assemblies’ seats where polls were postponed, Makhdoom Amin Faheem, Prime-Minister-in-waiting, ANP President Asfandyar Wali, PPP’s Punjab Chapter President Shah Mehmood Qureshi and PML-Q’ key leader Chaudhary Pervaiz Elahi are amongst those who are to vacate their provincial assemblies’ seats. Larkana Constituency (NA-207) of slain Benazir Bhutto is amongst those where the elections were postponed due to death of the contesting candidates. Other seats are NA-119 Lahore, NA-37 (Tribal Areas) and NA-42 (Tribal Areas) where the by-polls are to be held.

Election Tribunals Set-Up in Three Provinces

The Chief Election Commissioner has appointed election tribunals in Sindh, NWFP and Balochistan provinces to hear and dispose the election petitions. The tribunals have been appointed in pursuance of the provision of section 57 of the Representation of the People Act, 1976 (LXXXV of 1976) and in consultation with the Chief Justices of respective High Courts. The tribunal in Sindh Province includes Justice Azizullah M Memon, Mrs Justice Yasmin Abbasi, Justice Ali Sain Dino Metlo, Justice Syed Mahmood Alam Rizvi, Justice Agha Rafiq Ahmed Khan, Justice Syed Pir Ali Shah, Justice Arshad Noor Khan and Justice Dr Qamruddin Bohra. The tribunal in Balochistan includes Justices Akhtar Zaman Malghani and Mehta Kailash Nath Kohli. Justice Said Maroof Khan, Justice Hamid Farooq Durrani, Justice Shaji Rahman Khan, Justice Ghulam Mohy-ud-Din Malik, Justice Syed Yahya Zahid Gilani, Justice Ziauddin Khattak, Justice Syed Musadiq Hussain Gilani and Justice Alam Khan have been appointed to hear and dispose election petitions in the NWFP and FATA.

Election Results

Party

National Assembly

Punjab PA

Sindh PA

Balochistan PA

NWFP PA

 PPPP

87

80

69

7

17

 PML(N)

67

104

0

0

5

 PML(Q)

41

68

10

18

5

 MQM

19

0

39

0

0

 ANP

10

0

2

2

31

 MMA

6

2

0

7

10

 PML F

4

3

7

0

0

 BNP(A)

1

0

0

5

0

 PPP(S)

1

0

0

0

6

 NPP

2

0

3

0

0

 INDEPENDENT / OTHERS

29

35

0

12

21

 TOTAL RESULTS

267

292

130

51

95

TOTAL SEATS   CONTESTED 

268

292

130

51

96

19 PML-Q Federal Ministers Lose Seats

The pro-Musharraf Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid (PML-Q) suffered a stunning defeat in February 18’s polls, resulting in 19 hand-picked Federal Ministers losing their seats — mainly to PML-N candidates. The ministers evicted include: Omar Ayub Khan, Sheikh Rashid Ahmed, Amin Aslam, Humayun Akhtar, Awais Leghari, Khurshid Kasuri, Rao Sikander Iqbal, Nourez Shakoor, Khusro Bakhtiar, Zubaida Jalal, Dr Sher Afgan Niazi, Wasi Zafar, Naseer Khan, Liaquat Jatoi, Sikander Hayat Bosan, Mushtaq Cheema, Yar Muhammad Rind, Ijazul Haq and Danyal Aziz. National Assembly speaker Chaudhry Amir Hussain also lost out his seat in the government. Former prime minister Shaukat Aziz was not one of the losers, as he had left the country much before the elections when he was refused a PML-Q ticket. Meanwhile, the people who have won the elections and are likely to retain their seats include Aftab Ahmed Sherpao, Jehangir Tareen, Faisal Saleh Hayat, Zahid Hamid, Amir Muqam, Raza Hayat Hiraj and Hina Rabbani Khar. Aftab Sherpao was contesting from the platform of his own faction of the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP). Jehangir Tareen, Zahid Hamid and Hina Rabbani Khar won 2002 elections on PML-Q tickets, but this time they chose to contest them on the tickets of the PML-Functional, the PML-N and the PPPP. Faisal Saleh Hayat and Raza Hayat Hiraj had won the 2002 elections on PPP tickets, but later formed a separate faction called the PPP-Patriots. They then joined the PML-Q, along with other patriots, under the leadership of Rao Sikander Iqbal. Faisal Saleh Hayat and Raza Hayat Hiraj won their seats from PML-Q’s platform, defeating Syeda Abida Hussain and her husband Syed Fakhr Imam, respectively.

PPP, PML-Q get most Votes

Although there is a great difference in the number of seats won in the National Assembly (NA), the Pakistan Muslim League Quaid-e-Azam (PML-Q) has emerged second to the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) on account of votes received. According to a ‘Party-Wise Total Vote Bank’ sheet compiled by the Election Commission of Pakistan, the PPP has secured the largest number of votes in the 2008 general elections. The PPP received more than 15 million votes throughout the country for National Assembly seats. The PML-Q came second, securing around eight million votes. According to the sheet compiled Monday, the Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz (PML-N) came third, receiving around 6.8 million votes. Independent candidates secured fourth position, with around 3.7 million votes cast in their favour, while the Muttahida Qaumi Movement was fifth after receiving approximately 2.5 million votes. It is pertinent to mention that the results of, at least, 8 NA seats have yet to be announced, as the results are either pending or elections were not held in the constituencies.

PPP, PML-N, ANP Muster-Up 171 MNAs-Elect: For Now or Forever?

The Pakistan People’s Party (PPP), the Awami National Party (ANP) and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) – met at a luncheon on Wednesday to demonstrate their parliamentary strength on Wednesday. The joint meeting hosted by Zardari was attended by 171 MNAs-elect. Zardari, Nawaz and Wali reiterated their pledge to work together for the supremacy of parliament, the independence of judiciary and the rule of law on the occasion. PPP Co-chairman Asif Ali Zardari was quoted as saying that the new government would work towards changing the system and not personal revenge. PML-N Chief Nawaz Sharif, meanwhile, said that President Pervez Musharraf should resign immediately” ANP President Asfandyar Wali said that compromise could be used to resolve issues, but “principles should not be sacrificed”.

Prime Minister/Parliamentary Leaders/CMs

Mukhtar, Qureshi, Gillani in Run for Premiership

The Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) is most likely to nominate its candidate for the slot of Prime Minister from the Punjab and top contenders for the position are Ahmad Mukhtar, Shah Mahmood Qureshi and Yousaf Raza Gillani. Although Amin Fahim was pronounced the PPP’s parliamentary leader after the death of Benazir Bhutto, insiders said a consensus could not be built in the party on his candidature. “It seems he (Fahim) is out of the race,” an insider close to PPP Co-chairman Asif Zardari told Daily Times. The reason for the change of heart is that Zardari also belongs to Sindh. If Fahim is nominated for the slot of PM, the party’s top hierarchy would belong to only one province and Punjab will be neglected at a time when the party needs to be strengthened in the province. But Zardari is not dropping any hints about the PPP’s candidate because he is assessing the political situation and analysing the ground realities. Following a disagreement in the party on Fahim’s candidature, Ahmad Mukhtar, Shah Mehmood Qureshi and Yousaf Raza Gillani have started lobbying for the top slot. Qureshi is Cambridge educated and without any blot on his character. And like Fahim, he has also resisted pressure from different quarters to switch loyalty. Gillani is a former NA speaker and has suffered in jail for a long time. But like Qureshi, he also belongs to southern Punjab.

Elahi PML-Q Parliamentary Leader in NA

Pakistan Muslim League-Q announced that Chaudhry Pervaiz Elahi would be its Parliamentary Leader in the National Assembly and Hamid Nasir Chattha the Parliamentary Leader in the Punjab Assembly.

JUI-F Names NWFP Assembly Leader

The Executive Committee of the Balochistan Chapter of JUI-F has nominated Maulana Abdul Wasay as the party’s Parliamentary Leader in the Provincial Assembly. Addressing a press conference on February 25, Provincial Amir Maulana Mohammad Khan Sherani said that a five-member committee headed by Maulvi Ataullah would contact representatives of other political groups for forming a coalition government in the Province. Members of the committee are Maulana Wasay, Manzoor Mengal, Rehmatullah Kakar and Hafiz Hamadullah. Maulana Sherani claimed that after the Election Commission issued an official notification and the independent candidates announced their affiliations, the strength of each group in the house would become clear and talks could then be held with them for cooperation. He said the Executive Committee decided that dissidents who had formed their own group would have nothing to do with the Provincial Executive and questions about the dissidents should be addressed to central Amir Maulana Fazlur Rehman.

Achakzai to Lead ANP in Balochistan Assembly

Zamarak Khan Achakzai has been nominated as the Parliamentary leader of the Awami National Party in the Balochistan Assembly. A meeting held here on February 27 under the chairmanship of the party’s provincial president Khudadad Khan, formed a five-member committee to hold talks with other political groups for forming a coalition government in the province. The committee comprising Khudadad Khan, Zamarak Khan Achakzai, Nawabzada Ashraf Khan Jogezai, Azizullah Khan and Sultan Khan Kakar. The party has won two seats in the assembly in the Feb 18 elections, one from Qila Abdullah and the other from Harnai.

ANP Names Amir Hoti for Frontier CM Post

The Awami National Party nominated Bacha Khan’s great grandson Amir Haidar Khan Hoti for the post of Chief Minister in a coalition government with the PPP in the NWFP. Another serious contender for the job was ANP’s former Parliamentary Leader in the NWFP assembly, Bashir Ahmed Bilour, who will retain his job. The party said the decision to nominate Mr Hoti for the CM’s post had been taken unanimously. However, the decision irked Mr Bilour’s supporters who gathered outside the party’s headquarters, Bacha Khan Markaz, to protest against the nomination of Amir Hoti.Mr Bilour, however, pacified the charged activists. He also hosted a dinner for Mr Hoti and elected MPAs and party leaders at his house.

Born in Mardan on Feb 5, 1971, Haider Khan Hoti obtained his F.Sc certificate from the Aitchison College in Lahore and graduated from Edwards College in Peshawar. He entered politics in 1990. Son of former Federal Minister Mohammad Azam Khan Hoti and nephew of ANP President Asfandyar Wali Khan, Haider Hoti will be the youngest and 18th chief minister of the province. Party sources said Mr. Hoti enjoyed the trust and confidence of the ANP President and was committed to the party’s ideals.

Former CM Magsi Named Balochistan Governor

Former Balochistan chief minister Nawab Zulfikar Ali Magsi has been appointed to the post of Balochistan Governor. Well-placed sources in the Governor’s Secretariat have confirmed that the MPA-elect has been nominated as the next Governor of Balochistan. He is expected to take oath of office today (Thursday) at 11am in a ceremony being held at Governor’s House. Magsi won the Balochistan Assembly seat from PB-32 as an independent candidate despite having received an election ticket from the PML-Q. He would take oath as the 13th governor of Balochistan,

Women & Elections

Women as Contestants

15 Women make it to Parliament

Fifteen women made it to the National Assembly in the February 18’s elections. Pakistan People’s Party’s (PPP) Dr Firdous Ashiq Awan routed Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid’s (PML-Q) candidate and former National Assembly speaker Chaudhry Amir Hussain. In NA-225, Dr Fehmida Mirza of PPP defeated PML-Q’s Bibi Yasmeen Shah, bagging 88,983 votes. The PML-Q’s Ghulam Bibi Bharwana once again won NA-87 (Jhang-I) seat. Bharwana defeated PPP’s Syeda Sughra Imam, daughter of Begums Abida Hussain, bagging 63,506 votes. Pakistan People’s Party’s Co-Chairman Asif Ali Zardari’s sister Dr Azra Fazal Pecheho again made her way to the National Assembly from NA-213 (Nawabshah-I). She was polled 108,096, the highest votes among female winners. Shamshad Sattar Bachani of PPP defended her NA-223 seat by getting 84,630 votes. The PML-Q’s Raja Ali Khan Baloch failed to defend his seat NA-78 (Faisalabad-IV). He was defeated by PPP’s Rahila Parveen, who got 79,114 votes. Saima Akhtar Bharwana, won NA-90 (Jhang-V) seat as an independent candidate. She defeated PML-Q’s Sahibzada Muhammad Nazir Sultan getting 64,619 votes. She had won the seat on PML-Q ticket in 2002 elections. Farkhanda Amjad Warraich of PML-Q won NA-92 (T.T Singh-I) seat bagging 69,298 votes. Saira Afzal Tarar of PML-N was declared winner from NA-102 (Hafizabad-I) getting 56,313 votes.

Muttahida Qaumi Movement’s Khush Bakht Shujaat bagged 52,045 votes from NA-250 and was declared winner. Sumaira Malik of PML-Q contesting from NA-69 (Khushab-I) and Tehmina Daultana of PML-N contesting from NA-169 (Vehari-III) were in a strong position but the Election Commission of Pakistan had not posted their results on its website till the filing of this report in the evening. Former federal minister for social welfare Zobaida Jalal, who contested as an independent candidate after developing differences with PML-Q top brass, suffered defeat from NA-272 (Kech-cum-Gwadar).

The PPP’s Abida Hussain was defeated by former Federal Environment Minister Makhdoom Faisal Saleh Hayat in NA-88 (Jhang-III). Faisal was polled 72,065 votes.

Following list gives the details of party and province-wise details of winning women candidates on NA seats:

Result Sheet - Winning Women Candidates (National Assembly)

PPPP

Sr.No

Constituencies

Name

Votes Taken

1

NA-78 Faisalabad-IV

Rahila Parveen

79,114

2

NA-111 Sialkot-II

Dr. Fardos Ashiq Awan

78,925

3

NA-130 Lahore-XIII

Samina Khalid Ghurki

44,692

4

NA-177 Muzaffargarh-II

Hina Rabbani Khar

84,914

5

NA-213 Nawabshah-I

Azra Fazal Pecheho

1,08,096

6

NA-223 Tando Allahyar

Shamshad Sattar Bachani

84,630

7

NA-225 Badin-C-T M K-II

Dr. Fahmida Mirza

88,983

PML(Q)

Sr.No

Constituencies

Name

Votes Taken

1

NA-69 Khushab-I

Sumaira Malik

61,076

2

NA-87 Jhang-II

Ghulam Bibi Bharwana

63,506

3

NA-92 T.T. Singh-I

Farkhanda Amjad Warraich

69,298

PML(N)

Sr.No

Constituencies

Name

Votes Taken

1

NA-102 Hafizabad-I

Saira Afzal Tarar

56,313

2

NA-115 Narowal-I

Sumaira Naz

59,678

3

NA-169 Vehari-III

Tehmina Daultana

48,998

 

INDEPENDENT

Sr.No

Constituencies

Name

Votes Taken

1

NA-90 Jhang-V

Saima Akhtar Bharwana

64,619

Winning Candidates on PA Seats

Result Sheet- Winning Women Candidates (Provincial Assemblies)

Sr.No

Constituencies

Name

Party

Votes

Sindh

1

PS-85 Thatta-II

Sassui Palijo

PPPP

28,915

Balochistan

1

PB-17 Barkhan

Mrs. Nasreen Rehman Khetran

PML(Q)

12,409

Punjab

1

PP-8 Rawalpindi-VIII

Mrs. Umar Farooq

PML(N)

30,679

2

PP-20 Chakwal-I

Iffat Liaqat Ali Khan

PML(N)

50,039

3

PP-38 Sargodha-XI

Shahzadi Umerzadi Tiwana

PML(N)

56,659

4

PP-86 Toba Tek Singh-III

Neelam Jabbar Chaudhary

PPPP

22,850

5

PP-88 Toba Tek Singh-V

Nazia Raheel

PML(N)

23,472

6

PP-135 Narowal-IV

Samina Wasim Butt

PML(N)

42,787

7

PP-188 Okara-IV

Robina Shaheen Wattoo

Independent

29,252

8

PP-206 Multan-XIII

Naghma Mushtaq Lang

PML(Q)

28,104

PPP Ignores Seraiki Women to Favor Urban Elite Begums – Analysis by The News

It might sound a serious joke but it is a shocking fact now. The PPP got 23 seats of the National Assembly from the Seraiki region of southern Punjab, but instead of giving representation to the women of the area, the Begums of Islamabad and Lahore have been nominated the party for the reserved seats. While the PPP did not win many urban seats, the real sister of the Attorney General Pakistan Justice ® Malik Qayyum has also been nominated on women seats, surprising both for the National and Punjab Assemblies. She is the sister of the same judge who had sentenced Benazir Bhutto and Asif Zardari on corruption charges under pressure from the then prime minister and was then caught on tape and sacked. She is not the only who has been n0ominated both for the National and provincial assemblies on women seats. Many other privileged elite women also enjoy this exclusive status. The sister of AG was also an MNA from PPP in the previous assembly and hags once again retained her place. The PPP won 23 seats from districts like Muzaffargarh, Multan, Sahiwal, Vehari, Rajanpur, Bahawalnagar, and Rahim Yar Khan But, the list of women who would reach NA on the basis of vote from the region belong to Lahore and Islamabad or central Punjab where the party performed poorly. A total of about 20 women are set to reach parliament on the recommendation of PPP on the basis of seats obtained in the elections but none of them even speaks Seraiki. The Seraiki region has always been bailing out The PPP even, in difficult times, and the party reached the power corridors on the basis of electoral strength from this area populated with 40 million peoples. The most disappointing thing for Seraiki women and the voters would be that two stalwarts of the party from the region, Shah Mahmood Qureshi, President Punjab PPP and Yousaf Raza Gilani, senior vice chairman, were holding important posts in the party when the list was finalized and both of them did not consider any woman worth naming from Seraiki belt for parliament. The list shows that PPP has just nominated one Punjabi speaking woman from Multan, Begum Nasim Akhtar Chaudary, who was also MNA during 2002-2007 and the party did not think about placing her with some other dedicated worker from serakik region. Nasim never talked about any issue concerning the Seraiki women during these fice years in parliament. The most interesting inclusion in the list is Palwasha Behram, who emerged on the political scene hardly two years back but soon got popular among the party leaders and is set to reach parliament. Her nomination had generated controversy as she was served show cause notice for some of her actions. The list of the nominated women is given below along with their addresses to show where they belong: Rukhsana Bangash (48-KH-e-Eqbal F-7/2 Islamabad) Shahnaz Wazir Ali (85-Sarfraz Rafique dROad Lahore Cantt) Palwasha Muhammad Zal (Post office Khas Tehsil and District Chakewal) Begum Hasnain (46-E-1 Gulberg III Lahore) Mehreen Anwar Raja (71-A Shah jamal Lahore ) Farzaqna Raja (Village Chak Ragran Tehsil Gujjar Khan District Rawalpindi) Justice ® Fakrun nisa Khokar )A-40 CMA Colony Lahore Cantt) Fauzi8a Habib (18-E Saidpur Road Rawalpindi) Ms. Shakeela Khanum Rasheed ( 189, Shadman-II Lhaore) Mrs Yaseen Rehman (19-Shah Jamal Lhoare) Samina Mushtaq Pugganwala, (Pugganwala House Gujrat) Nargis Faiz Malik (EN 1003 Gali No 5, Dhoke Hukkam Dad Rawalpindi) Dr. Nagina Sadaf (H.N 21/3 Munshi Mohallah Mandi Bahauddin) Shabnam Waseem (60-x Phase-III DHA Lahore) Nishat Afza (Chak No 391/JB To0ba Tek Singh) Uzma Fida Khawja (258-D peoples Colony, Faisalabad) and Zarqa But ( House # 33, St# 51, Islampura Shahdara Lahore).

Talking to The News PPP spokesman Farahtullah Babar said he did not know about the exact number o0f women nominated from Punjavb and Seraiki region though he confirmed that the party had won 23 seats alone from this region. He did not agree that the elite women from Islamabad and Lahore were nominated to grab the parliamentary seats in the jparliament. Babar said there was proper system for nomination of women, which might have been followed by the party leaders at the time of nomination oif those ladies.

Women as Voters

Women Barred from Voting in Parts of Peshawar, Malakand

As feared, women were barred from casting votes in certain parts of the provincial metropolis and the erstwhile Malakand division. Interestingly, candidates of all political parties in Peshawar agreed to exclude women voters from polling. At one of the polling stations in the Provincial Assembly Constituency, PF-8 Peshawar VIII, the Presiding Officer shown a written agreement to a media team banning female voting in the Constituency. Against the provisions of the Constitution and democratic norms, the candidates of almost all political parties contesting from the Constituency had signed the accord. The agreement said that it is not the tradition of Pakhtuns to hold women polling and therefore they had decided to keep the tradition intact. Women could not use their right to vote in Hazarkhwani, Pandu, Sheikh Mohammadi and other areas of Peshawar. Turnout of the women, where they were allowed to exercise their right to vote, remained thin. In Dir Upper, Dir Lower and Swat districts, women could not even cast a single vote. A total of 89,055 registered female voters in Dir Upper and 145,337 voters in Dir Lower stayed away from electoral process. However, women were able to cast vote at few polling stations in Shangla district, the hometown of former Federal Minister Amir Muqam.

Election Observers

The Researchers (TR)

According to the preliminary report issued by TR, a total of 192 women contestant entered the political arena for 176 national and Provincial Assembly constituencies in General Election 2008. TR selected 65 National and Provincial Assembly constituencies (37%) to observe elections nationwide which includes 37(59%) constituencies of National Assembly and 28 (25%) of Provincial Assembly. The selection of these constituencies was done primarily to cover maximum seats where women are contesting elections against open seats. Preference was given to those where women were seats holder of a political party however this did not exclude women contesting independently.

TR issued its preliminary report on the Observation of 65 Women Contested Constituencies on February 20, 2008. Aazar Ayaz, Executive Director of TR presented the report at South Asian Free Media Association (SAFMA). Addressing media persons at a press conference, Executive Director said that TR focused on the research based observation of women contested constituencies in the Election 2008 and decided to dedicate the report to Mrs. Benazir Bhutto, which set course for return to people centered democracy despite heavy criticism and critique. He said that TR has undertaken desk and field work which is observatory-cum-research based. He said that TR selected 65 National and Provincial assembly constituencies to observe elections nationwide. A total of 192 women contest entered in political arena for 176 National and Provincial Assembly constituencies in General Election 2008. In report TR observed that electoral processes relating instructions and codes were gender blind. Data assessment observed that voter list-marginalized women as approximately 8-10 million women voters missing for range of reasons. Report hinted that ECP failed to exert control on political interference of local Nazims in favor of sitting government. About Election Day observations, report said several incidents of women being barred from voting were reported form the some constituencies of Punjab and NWFP. Report mentioned that TR observed a total 797 polling stations with the 194 males and 198 females’ observers. The area selected for these polling stations were one team in urban area, one team in pre-urban and two in rural areas.Teams observed on polling day that 90 percent staff was present in observed polling stations. Polling staff’s training as described by majority was limited hence those who had not performed election duty earlier had difficulties.

Report recommended that voter list is incomplete and controversial, ECP should start efforts to clean and update the data so that duplicate entries and missing women can be added to list before local elections in 2009. It further recommended that voter list data be re-verified and linked with NADRA date base so that each new person receiving a CNIC is added into voter list. It reported that government and political parties should facilitate women to get CNIC. Detailed report is available on following link:

http://www.theresearchers.org/PreliminaryReport.pdf

European Union (EU)

Preliminary assessment of European Union Election Observation Mission (EU EOM) concluded that the National and Provincial Assembly elections were competitive and the polling process achieved increased public confidence, but there were significant problems with the election framework and environment. Chief Observer Michael Gahler said that the Mission is currently observing the results consolidation process and will remain in Pakistan to observe post election developments, including complaints and appeals. He called for “all outstanding complaints and appeals against the results to be processed quickly, impartially and transparently”, as well as the publication of detailed results by polling station. Gahler added that a final report containing detailed recommendations for the future, will be published within two months of the completion of the entire process. Preliminary assessment can be accessed through following link:

http://www.eueompakistan.org/PDF/preliminary/Preliminary%20Statement%20Pakistan%2020%20February2.pdf

National Democratic Institute (NDI) and Centre for Civic Education (CCE)

EC Response to Complaints Taints Polls Fairness

Representatives of five major political parties at a roundtable expressed their disappointment over the inaction of Election Commission over more than two thousand complaints which seriously limited the transparency and fairness of February 18 general elections. The representatives of Pakistan People’s Party, Pakistan Muslim League (N), Pakistan Muslim League (Q), Jamiat Ulema Islam (F) and Muttahida Qaumi Movement participated in the roundtable, which was organized by National Democratic Institute for International Affairs (NDI) and Centre for Civic Education (CCE).

The parties developed specific recommendations to improve the electoral process including the need to resolve election petitions in the legally prescribed time. They also recommended a revision of the Code of Conduct in consultation with the political parties to include transparent and timely mechanisms for monitoring and adjudicating complaints. The recommendations of the party representatives are as follows:

  • The ECP should ensure that the notification of returned candidates is issued without delay, as specified in the law and the sessions of the assemblies should be called immediately thereafter.
  • The NADRA database should be used to verify accuracy of the voters’ lists and the revised lists should be made readily available to political parties and civil society for review prior to finalization.
  • Obstacles in obtaining computerised national identity cards should be eliminated such as bureaucratic delays and inaccessibility of NADRA offices.
  • All those who receive a CNIC should be automatically registered as voters.
  • The polling scheme should be announced at least two weeks prior to polling day. The ECP should be responsible for informing voters in which polling station and polling booth they should cast vote.
  • The ECP should provide each candidate with the exact number of postal ballots printed and issued for their constituency before election day.
  • The ECP and government should play their due role to prevent and check polling day violence and to guarantee a safe environment for voters, polling officials, political parties, polling agents, observers and media.
  • The ECP should take adequate measures to ensure that women are able to exercise their right to vote.
  • This should include female enumerators during registration, providing adequate number of polling booths and staff for women, enhance voter education in areas with low female voter turnout, and collect data on female voter turnout.
  • MQM and PML-Q agreed that where women were barred from voting the election should be declared null and void. PPP and PML-N demanded an inquiry as per law where such incidents occurred and strict punishment for violations.
  • The Government should lift all restrictions on freedom of the media, including the repeal of the new PEMRA ordinances. MQM added that the media should act responsibly. The ECP, in consultation with media and political parties, should develop elections Code of Conduct for public and private media and ensure equitable access to public media for all contestants in the elections.
  • Pakistan People’s Party and Pakistan Muslim League-N reiterated their demand to suspend local governments during the election period adding that their concerns about the interference of nazims proved correct.

Farzana Raja (PPP), Senator Azam Swati (JUI-F), Haider Abbas Rizvi (MQM), Barrister Zafarullah Khan (PML-N) and Umar Masood (PML-Q) spoke on behalf of their parties. CCE Director Zafarullah Khan moderated the roundtable and NDI Country Director Sheila Furman also spoke on the occasion.

Center for Media and Democracy (CMD)

According to the report of Center for Media and Democracy Pakistan (CMD), the February 18 elections saw a 3.93 percent increase in the voter turnout despite pre-poll forecasts of low turnout due to terrorist threat and boycott calls by some political parties and the lawyers’ movement, says a CMD report issued February 20. The voter turnout was 45.67, up from 41.74 percent in 2002 elections, The report said voter turnout touched 49.34 percent in Punjab while it had remained at 46.46 percent in the previous polls. People in Sindh also put all the threats aside and enthusiastically participated in the polls which pushed the voter turnout up by 7.3 percent, as it was 38.22 percent in year 2002. The people of Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) also defied the terrorist threat and the turnout touched 26.91 in contrast to that of 25.53 percent in the previous elections. The turnout in the Federal Capital saw a slight decline. It was 49.98 percent whereas in 2002 the figure was 51.28 percent. NWFP people also came out of their homes shrugging off the boycott calls and threats by terrorist elements. Though the turnout was slightly less than the previous polls which stood at 34.22 percent, the voter turnout touched a surprising 33.91 percent which was a positive development. Substantial increase in the voter turnout of mainstream political parties was also witnessed. The voter turnout of Pakistan Peoples Party was 43.37 for its 87 national assembly seats, while the Pakistan Muslim League-N polled votes at 46.64 percent for 67 national assembly seats. The turnout for 40 national assembly seats of Pakistan Muslim League-Q touched 50.18 percent. The turnout for 19 NA seats won by MQM candidates remained at 50.56 percent while the same was 29.35 percent for 9 NA seats of Awami National Party (ANP). The voter ratio for 5 Mutahidda Majlis-e-Amal (MMA) and 4 Pakistan Muslim League (Functional) seats remained 36.46 percent and 48.88 percent respectively. The International Observer Group of the Center for Media and Democracy, Pakistan (CMD) has also compiled their report on the monitoring of the polls process.

The International Observer Group unanimously declares the electoral process transparent.

Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN)

Issuing a preliminary report, the FAFEN has said that according to their observers’ reports in more than 53 percent of the polling stations 400 or more votes polled by the end of the day, out of on average registered voters of 1000 to 1200 voters. The report is based on information gathered by the FAFEN call centre operators by speaking to 202 FAFEN constituency coordinators. The data is based on the information from 7,814 polling stations observed by the FAFEN. Detailed report is available on: http://www.fafen.org/pressdet.php?id=89

Pakistan Institute for Legislative Development and Transparency (PILDAT)

In order to analyze the polling day and post-poll process after February 18 General Election, the Citizens Group on Electoral Process – CGEP met in Islamabad on February 21 under the Chairmanship of Justice (Retd.) Saeed uz Zaman Siddiqiui and issued the following statement. “We salute the people of Pakistan for reaffirming their unequivocal commitment to democracy and constitutionalism. They have defeated all the conspiracies conducted in the pre-poll phase seeking to distort the popular will.

According to the analysis by CGEP : The polling process on election-day was generally free and fair though The results may have been more reflective of the will of the people but for serious flaws both before and during the serious complaints from a number of constituencies need to be addressed through an independent judicial process. polls. There appears to have been a clear intent and plan by the Government to support its favourite parties by direct and indirect means. Fortunately, this plan was thwarted by the vigilance and the dedication of civil society and the media. It is a welcome development that the results of the election have been accepted by all the major political parties. It is now incumbent on all concerned, including, in particular, the leaders of the political parties, to ensure that the mandate given by the people to the new National and Provincial Assemblies is respected both in letter and spirit. The majority parties in each Assembly should exercise their right to form the governments without any pressure or interference from the Presidency, caretaker government, agencies and foreign governments.

Pakistan Coalition for Free, Fair and Democratic Elections (PACFREL)

A collaboration of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and a small number of foreign observers from South Asian countries have said in a report that the Election Commission’s (EC) impartiality can be questions due to problems in the voter lists and glitches in the election process. The report published by the collaboration, known as the Pakistan Coalition for Free, Fair and Democratic Elections (PACFREL), says that foreign observers were from Bangladesh, Nepal and Afghanistan and the NGOs that joined the coalition included the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, Ecumenical Advocacy Forum, South Asia Partnership Pakistan, Aurat Foundation, SUNGI Development Foundation, Interactive Resource Centre and Pakistan Institute for Labour Education and Research.

The report says the voter lists were not well prepared and at some polling stations wrong lists were found in circulation. Wrong ballot papers with same serial number were also found both for national and provincial elections. It says that the partiality of the EC has also been questioned by political parties. The report says that it was based on the observation of 2,200 volunteers who monitored 110 National Assembly constituencies. The report says polling started at about 8:30pm in general. It says that at several polling stations concerned polling agents we not present. For example, it says, like NA 139, Kasur, where polling could not start before 9:17am. The report also observes that voting turnout was comparatively higher in rural areas than in urban areas. In several areas, unconcerned people were seen going inside polling stations. Women’s voting turnout was generally low, as in NA 140 the first woman who cast her vote was no before than 1pm. In some areas of the Punjab and NWFP, it says, women were not allowed to cast vote. In Swabi women were completely barred from taking part in elections and the locals had said that if any woman votes, she would have to pay Rs 200,000. Incidents of violence, rigging, theft of ballot papers and involvement of local administration in some areas amounts to mismanagement and inadequate arrangements made by the EC, the report said.

Post-Elections Senate

Elections of Senators to NA – Two Senate Seats of NWFP to Fall Vacant

After being elected to the National Assembly, Senator Asfandyar Wali Khan and Senator Sardar Mehtab Ahmed Khan have to resign from the Upper House of the Parliament. Both Asfandyar and Sardar Mehtab were elected Senators on General Seats in 2003 from NWFP and were to compete their tenure in February next year but they preferred to contest elections for the National Assembly. Asfandyar, President of ANP, contested for NA-7 Charsada and NA-12 Swabi seats and won by a big margin in his hometown Constituency but lost to an independent candidate, Usman Tarakai, in NA-12 Swabi by a margin of only 89 votes. Former NWFP Chief Minister Sardar Mehtab has been elected on the PML-N ticket from NA-17 bbotbad and PF-45 Abbotabad simultaneously. The result of another Senator from Khyber Agency Hamidullah Jan Afridi is yet to be announced but according to the results collected from various polling stations; he had an edge over other candidate in NA-46 Tribal Area. Three MMA Senators, Maulana Gul Naseeb Khan, Sahibzada Khalid Jan and Senator Rahat Hussain, also contested but faced a defeat.

Enjoying majority in the newly elected NWFP Assembly, the ANP and PPP are in a better position to grab the two vacant seats in the Senate from the Frontier. It will be premature to say who would be nominated by the ANP, PPP and PML-N but surely many have started lobbying for the two Senate seats.

6 PML-Q Senators Formed Forward Bloc

As many as six Senators led by Senator Nilofar Bakhtiar of former ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid-e-Azam (PML-Q) and its allied parties have formed a forward bloc. Forward bloc comprises of Senators Amjad Abbas, Wali Muhammad Badeni, Chaudhry Zafar Iqbal, Nilofar Bakhtiar from PML-Q, Israr Ullah Zehri from Balochistan National Party (BNP) and Asif Jatoi of National Peoples Party (BNP).

Addressing a press conference on February 26, Senator Nilofar Bakhtiar said they have no differences with any party nor they have their personal agenda. "We will stay in our party and will support all those steps of next government which it would take in the national interest. Provincial autonomy is at the top of our agenda, she said. We want to work with for independence of judiciary, provincial autonomy, media protection and repeal of clause 58 (2b) from the Constitution, she added. "We want to work for Pakistan. We would have joint stance over national issues," said Nilofar adding that we will support all those organisations, which desire democracy in Pakistan.

"We will see when impeachment move comes against the President", she held. Several other senators want to join us and they will soon be on our side", she pointed out.

She clarified that ministries are not their objective yet they want restoration of judiciary. Nilofar recalled that past government had developed proposals over provincial autonomy but it was lacking implementation. Responding a question Senator Wali Badini said their group would support the bill for the restoring the deposed judges. We did wait, he said, for the provincial autonomy bill but it was not moved.

Other News

PPP, PML-N can Impeach Musharraf: US Official

US intelligence czar Michael McConnel has said that two major parties in Pakistan, PPP and PML-N, could impeach President Musharraf if they are backed by the independents while top US diplomat Negroponte said that the Bush administration is distancing itself from Musharraf. National Intelligence Director Michael McConnel said that we are watching very closely now to see how the coalition is formed, who the members will be and who the prime minister might be, Stating that Nawaz Sharif had an agenda to impeach President Musharraf, McConnel said that the PPP and PML-N do not have the votes to do that, but if the independents join them, they could possibly have the votes. On being asked the Chairman of Senate Armed Services Committee Carl Levin about the fairness of the polls, he said all the reporting he saw was they were - by Pakistani standards, reasonable and fair. The numbers of people voting were a little higher than anticipated and a little higher than average for Pakistan. It was over 40 per cent." Responding to a question if the polls were a repudiation of Islamic extremism, he said, "What I would highlight is those Islamic extremists that had been serving in the assembly were defeated in this election. So at that level, the parties that won are more secular. So there is some level of repudiating extremism."

Meanwhile, Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte on February 28 signalled that the Bush administration is distancing itself from President Pervez Musharraf after opposition parties' victory in elections. Negroponte told senators that the United States is supporting Pakistan's people as they choose their leaders after the parliamentary elections. But he made scant mention of Musharraf, during his testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. Senior Bush administration officials, including Negroponte, have previously underlined their view that Musharraf has been "indispensable" to the US-led fight against extremists along Pakistan's rugged border with Afghanistan. Negroponte testified that "Pakistan has been indispensable" to that fight and said the US looks "forward to working with the leaders who emerge" from the formation of a new government. When pressed by a lawmaker about whether the US would continue to back Musharraf, Negroponte acknowledged that "Musharraf is still the president of his country, and we look for to continuing to work with him." Negroponte said Pakistan's recent elections were a "big step" toward civilian democracy and reflected the will of the voters, despite the deaths of more than 70 people on elections day. "The violence could have been worse," Negroponte said. "The Pakistani people refused to be intimidated by a wave of murderous terrorist attacks prior to elections day." Democratic Sen Joe Biden also urged the administration to move from "a policy focused on a personality, Musharraf, to one based on an entire country." Biden proposed that the United States triple non-military aid for schools, roads and clinics and demand accountability in the military aid the US gives to Pakistan.

Back to top

 


Governance at Large

Laws / Orders / Ordinances

Apex Court Clears NRO

On February 27, the Supreme Court vacated its order of freezing two sections of the National Reconciliation Ordinance 2007, thereby allowing beneficiaries to enjoy the fruit of the ordinance. The ordinance was promulgated by President Pervez Musharraf in October last year to provide amnesty to public office-holders charged in corruption cases between 1986 and 1999. A five-member bench of the Apex Court comprising Chief Justice Abdul Hameed Dogar, Justice Mohammad Nawaz Abbasi, Justice Faqir Mohammad Khokhar, Justice Ijaz-ul-Hassan and Justice Chaudhry Ejaz Yousaf also dismissed three of the five identical petitions moved against the NRO because their counsel were not present to pursue the case. The Court ordered deletion of a paragraph from the order inserted earlier on the directives of a pre-emergency bench headed by deposed Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry preventing the beneficiaries of the ordinance from claiming any protection of a concluded action in any pending cases under sections 6 and 7 of the NRO. The apex court asked the courts concerned to pursue pending cases with them in accordance with the ordinance which now was a law. On Oct 12, 2007, a bench had described the ordinance as being against the public interest because it gave a blanket cover to people having committed corruption and held that any action and benefit drawn or intended to be drawn by any of the public office-holders would be subjected to the decision of the pending petitions.

Main beneficiaries of the law are the MQM, PML-Q, PML-N and PPP and some former bureaucrats and military officers. On February 27, the court dismissed the petitions filed by PML-N president Shahbaz Sharif, Jamaat-i-Islami chief Qazi Hussain and Tariq Asad. Advocates-on-record of Mr Sharif and Qazi Hussain Ahmed told the court that they had no instruction to pursue the case while Tariq Asad was not present. Former PPP stalwart Dr Mubashar Hasan and retired bureaucrat Roedad Khan pleaded for adjournment till March 14 saying their counsel Abdul Hafeez Pirzada was abroad for medical reasons and doctors had advised him not to travel for at least a week. Attorney General Malik Mohammad Qayyum said the matter deserved immediate attention, but it was ironic that none of the counsel was present in the court. He argued that under the Provisional Constitution Order and the recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the Nov 3 emergency case, the NRO was protected and had assumed a permanent character and could be undone only by Parliament. Advocates General of Balochistan, Sindh and the NWFP and the prosecutor general of National Accountability Bureau were present during the hearing. In their pleas, the petitioners had argued that the president had no authority to suspend or give indemnity on pending cases.

Governance & HR Issues

US to Review Child Labour Situation in Pakistan

The United States will review the child labour in nine countries, including Pakistan and if it is found in any country, the Trade Policy Staff Committee (TPSC) will commend to eliminate the special preference of GSP for three years. Official of the Ministry of Commerce told that US has started review of the child labour situation in nine countries, including Pakistan. These countries are exporting carpets to US under Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) Programme. The sources said that if the situation is unsatisfactory the TPSC would recommend to the US President to eliminate the special preference of GSP for three years. The US GSP subcommittee of the TPSC is conducting a review of whether each beneficiary country is taking steps to eliminate the worst forms of child labour, including the use of bonded child labour, in the production of such carpets imported under the US GSP program. The top suppliers of these carpets under the GSP program to the United States in 2006 were Pakistan, India, Thailand, Philippines, Indonesia, Egypt, Turkey, South Africa, and Nepal.

United States Trade Representative (USTR) has, in this regard, issued GSP notice regarding the initiation of child labour review in the production of certain GSP-eligible hand-loomed or hand-hooked carpets. The 2004 Miscellaneous Trade and Technical Corrections Act as approved by US Congress, authorized the US President to designate seven tariff lines relating to carpets (5702.51.20 (now 5702.50.20), 5702.91.30, 5702.92.00 (now 5702.92.10), 5702.99.10 (now 5702.99.05), 5703.10.00 (now 5703.10.20), 5703.20.10, and 5703.30.00 (now 5703.30.20) as eligible for duty-free treatment under the GSP program. These tariff lines cover certain hand-loomed or hand-hooked carpets and other textile floor coverings made of wool, cotton, fine animal hair, or man-made textile materials.

For purposes of this review, the term ‘‘worst forms of child labour’’ has been used which means that (a) all forms of slavery or practices similar to slavery, such as the sale or trafficking of children, debt bondage and serfdom, or forced or compulsory labour, including forced or compulsory recruitment of children for use in armed conflict (b) The use, procuring, or offering of a child for prostitution, for the production of pornography or for pornographic purposes; (c) The use, procuring, or offering of a child for illicit activities in particular for the production and trafficking of drugs; and (d) Work which, by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, is likely to harm the health, safety, or morals of children. The work referred to in subparagraph (d) shall be determined by the laws, regulations, or competent authority of the beneficiary developing country involved.

Surveys

93 Percent of Muslims Moderate – Survey by Gallup Polling Agency

A huge survey of the world's Muslims, released on February 26, challenges Western notions that equate Islam with radicalism and violence. The survey, conducted by the Gallup polling agency over six years and three continents, seeks to dispel the belief held by some in the West that Islam itself is the driving force of radicalism. It shows that the overwhelming majority of Muslims condemned the attacks against the United States on September 11, 2001 and other subsequent terrorist attacks, the authors of the study said in Washington. Samuel Harris said in the Washington Times (in 2004): 'It is time we admitted that we are not at war with terrorism. We are at war with Islam'," Dalia Mogahed, co-author of the book "Who Speaks for Islam" which grew out of the study, told a news conference here. She said that the argument Mr Harris makes is that religion in the primary driver" of radicalism and violence. Religion is an important part of life for the overwhelming majority of Muslims, and if it were indeed the driver for radicalization, this would be a serious issue.

Mogahed, Director of the Gallup Center for Muslim Studies said that the study, which Gallup says surveyed a sample equivalent to 90 percent of the world's Muslims, showed that widespread religiosity "does not translate into widespread support for terrorism," About 93 percent of the world's 1.3 billion Muslims are moderates and only seven percent are politically radical, according to the poll, based on more than 50,000 interviews.

In majority Muslim countries, overwhelming majorities said religion was a very important part of their lives -- 99 percent in Indonesia, 98 percent in Egypt, 95 percent in Pakistan. But only seven percent of the billion Muslims surveyed -- the radicals -- condoned the attacks on the United States in 2001, the poll showed. Moderate Muslims interviewed for the poll condemned the 9/11 attacks on New York and Washington because innocent lives were lost and civilians kille. Meanwhile, radical Muslims gave political, not religious, reasons for condoning the attacks, the poll showed. The survey shows radicals to be neither more religious than their moderate counterparts, nor products of abject poverty or refugee camps.

Gallup launched the study following 9/11, after which US President George W. Bush asked in a speech, which is quoted in the book: "Why do they hate us?" "They hate... a democratically elected government," Bush offered as a reason. "They hate our freedoms -- our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other." But the poll, which gives ordinary Muslims a voice in the global debate that they have been drawn into by 9/11, showed that most Muslims -- including radicals -- admire the West for its democracy, freedoms and technological prowess. What they do not want is to have Western ways forced on them, it said. Mogahed said that the poll has given voice to Islam's silent majority. Muslims in 40 countries in Africa, Asia, Europe and the Middle East were interviewed for the survey, which is part of Gallup's World Poll that aims to interview 95 percent of the world's population.

CIVICUS Global Survey of the State of Civil Society

CIVICUS is publishing the second volume of the CIVICUS Global Survey of the State of Civil Society which provides a wide-ranging analysis of key issues facing civil society worldwide. Comprising 24 chapters by prominent researchers and civil society practitioners, the book draws on the information collected by the CIVICUS Civil Society Index project in more than 45 countries to explore issues such as civil society’s accountability, its relations to the state and corporate sector and its role in governance and development. It also includes regional overviews of the state of civil society in different continents. By bringing together a diversity of perspectives and themes, this book offers one of the most comprehensive and engaging analyses of civil society worldwide.

For details see: www.civicus.org/new/content/CIVICUSGlobalSurvey-State-CivilSociety.html

Back to top


Geo-Political Dynamics



South Asia

IPI Accord to be signed in March

The Senate Standing Committee on Petroleum and Natural Resources was informed on Monday that Pakistan and Iran would formally sign an agreement on Iran-Pakistan-India (IPI) gas pipeline project in March. Briefing the committee, Ministry of Petroleum secretary Farrukh Qayyum said Pakistan had already initiated work on the project and technical details were being worked out with Iran. Under the agreement, Iran would supply 2.10 billion cubic feet of natural gas to Pakistan on a daily basis, for a period of 25 years with a delivery point pressure of 798 PSI. The Committee directed the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Resources to complete its homework and intensify its efforts for land acquisition. The Committee directed the ministry to mark contours and alignments to complete the gigantic project on time.

Bangladesh Court says Hasina Trial Unlawful

Bangladesh’s High Court ruled on February 6 that an ongoing corruption trial of former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina under emergency rules was unlawful. The court issued the ruling after an appeal from Hasina challenging the legality of a trial under emergency rules for a crime allegedly committed before the imposition of the emergency, lawyers and court officials said. Within hours, the army-backed interim government filed a counter appeal to the Supreme Court seeking a stay or reversal of the High court decision. Court officials said that the Supreme Court is expected to hear the appeal. A special court has been prosecuting Hasina and her cousin, former Minister Sheikh Selim, for allegedly taking 30 million taka ($440,000) from a businessman when Hasina was in power between 1996 and 2001. Hasina and Selim deny the charges. If the decision goes against the government, the corrupt leaders will be prosecuted in normal quick trial courts. Hasina’s Awami League party hailed the High Court ruling and demanded her release. Acting Chief of the Party Zillur Rahman said that after the High Court ruling the government has no right to detain her any more and she should be released immediately.

Nepal Seals Deal to End Protests – A Boost for Poll

Nepal's Government agreed, on February 28, to give autonomy to its southern plains in a deal to end an ethnic strike that had strangled the capital. The move, which came after days of talks between government negotiators and ethnic Madheshi protest leaders, has cleared the way for a twice-delayed election set for April 10 to be held. The election will choose a special assembly meant to map the country's political future and write a new constitution. That assembly may double as an interim Parliament. Both sides said in a statement that the ongoing protests have been withdrawn with immediate effect. The Government agreed to grant autonomy to the Terai, home to half the country's population, and other regions after the election was held. The protests, which reignited this month in the Terai, blocked the supplies of virtually all essential goods, including fuel, from the Indian border to Kathmandu. Five people died in the latest protests, while at least 45 were killed in violence in the Terai last year. The crisis had overshadowed a 2006 peace deal with Maoist rebels after a decade-long civil war which killed more than 13,000 people.

Southeast Asia

Malaysia Announces Polls on March 8

Malaysia's general elections will take place on March 8, the Election Commission said on February 14 a day after Parliament was dissolved. Election Commission chairman Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman said that EC has fixed the nomination date for February 24 and polling will be on March 8. Abdul Rashid defended the short campaign period, which is in line with previous elections in Malaysia, which has been ruled by the Barisan Nasional multi-ethnic coalition since independence half a century ago. He said that we are for fair elections. Rigging means you change the contents of the ballot box. He further said that there are no phantom voters.

Malaysia's opposition parties have attacked the timing of the polls, which are being held in advance of a May 2009 deadline, as well as the decision to dissolve parliament during Chinese Lunar New Year celebrations. Dissident former Deputy Premier Anwar Ibrahim, who was sacked and jailed in 1998, said the government was attempting to sideline him by holding the ballot just a month before he is eligible to run for office. Anwar said Abdullah was rushing to the polls after his approval ratings dropped to an all-time low.

Thailand gets Thaksin-Flavoured Cabinet

Thailand’s new cabinet, packed with supporters of ousted Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra, was sworn in by King Bhumibol Adulyadej onJanuary 6, marking the return of elected government after a 2006 coup. Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej, who admitted before the December 23 poll he was a proxy for Thaksin, doubled as Defence Minister - a slap in the face for the generals who led the coup and an indicator of how low their political star has fallen. Other important posts went to top officials of the People Power Party (PPP), the successor to Thaksin’s Thai Rak Thai (Thais Love Thais) party, banned after the coup for electoral fraud. Despite an army-led campaign to discredit Thaksin, his mainly rural supporters flocked to vote in the December election, pushing the PPP to just short of a clear majority and making it the dominant force in a six-party coalition.

Former Thaksin spokesman Surapong Suebwonglee, a doctor whose family owns a network of weight-loss clinics, became finance minister and Thaksin’s Oxford-educated lawyer, Noppadon Pattama, Foreign Minister. Mingkwan Sangsuwan, formerly a senior marketing executive at Toyota’s Thai operations, took the commerce portfolio with a remit to direct microeconomic policy. Thaksin’s brother-in-law, Somchai Wongsawat, became one of Samak’s six deputy prime ministers - and in all probability the conduit through which Thaksin will exert his influence from exile in London and Hong Kong. Thaksin opponents are already dubbing it a “puppet cabinet”. “Most cabinet decisions will be made outside of Government House - both domestically and overseas,” Suriyasai Katasila, who led mass-street protests against Thaksin in late 2005 and 2006. His comments raised the prospect of a revival of the protest movement that brought more than 100,000 people to the streets of Bangkok at its height to accuse Thaksin of being corrupt, abusive and disrespectful to the monarchy. Analysts say the protests and subsequent coup were also the Bangkok-based royalist and military elite reacting to the unprecedented power of Thaksin, an ethnic Chinese provincial billionaire whose popularity was built on lavish rural handouts. Thaksin has been cleared of any insult to the crown, but is facing one corruption charge relating to his wife’s purchase of a prime piece of Bangkok real estate while in office.

Thaksin Returns to Thailand amid Cheers, Tears

Ousted Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra made an emotional return from exile on February 28, preaching reconciliation and forgiveness in a country still polarized by his five years in elected office. He said that we can certainly have numerous opinions on various things, but we shall not be divided. However, few Thais believe - or want to believe - the 58-year-old’s mantra that he is returning only to clear himself of corruption charges and to spend quality time with the family after 18 months of exile enforced by a September 2006 coup. The cheers and tears from the thousands who greeted him at Bangkok’s new airport suggest the only elected Thai Prime Minister to complete a full term in office will not be allowed to stay out of the political fray for long - even if he wanted to. The big question is whether he does indeed take a back seat or whether he uses allies swept to power in a December election to go after the generals and the royalist elite who ousted him. The People’s Alliance for Democracy, which led the protest marches against Thaksin that culminated in the coup, has already warned Thaksin not to use political clout to sway the corruption cases against him and his wife.

Within minutes of arriving, Thaksin surrendered himself to the police, and then with tears in his eyes, left the terminal to kneel and place his forehead on the ground, his palms clasped together in a gesture of traditional respect for his motherland. Thousands of supporters waved roses and banners inscribed with ‘We love Thaksin’ cheered their hero, who was then whisked away in a motorcade of limousines to the Supreme Court, where he was granted a 8 million baht ($ 268,500) bail. Thaksin, accused of presiding over rampant corruption and disrespecting revered King Bhumibol Adulyadej, protested his innocence and insisted his political career was over. “I’ll just voice concerns as a former prime minister, if I were to have any,” he told reporters on the plane, a celebratory glass of champagne in his hands.

Myanmar to Bar Suu Kyi from 2010 Polls: Report

Singapore Foreign Minister George Yeo said his Myanmar counterpart told a regional meeting on February 19 that the new Constitution barred Suu Kyi from the polls because of her marriage to Briton Michael Aris, who died in 1999, and because their children held foreign passports, the newspaper said. Yeo said foreign ministers of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) told Myanmar's representative, Nyan Win, that the move was not in keeping with the times. He was quite clear that in the new Constitution, a Myanmar citizen who has a foreign husband or who has children not citizens of Myanmar will be disqualified, as it was in the 1974 constitution. Earlier this month, Myanmar's ruling General’s announced a referendum in May on a new constitution, to be followed by an election in 2010. The General’s last held elections in 1990, but ignored them when Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy won a landslide. The Nobel Peace Prize laureate has spent more than 12 of the past 18 years under some form of detention.

US Presidential Elections

Obama Repeats Threat to Attack Targets inside Pakistan, Hillary Calls it Unwise

Pakistan once again was on the centre of the US Presidential debate with Barack Obama repeating his threat to bomb ‘actionable’ terrorist targets inside the country while his main rival Hillary Clinton called it an unwise move. During a key debate before February 27’s do-or-die nomination contests in Ohio and Texas, Mr Obama also hinted that a recent US air strike at an Al-Qaeda target in North Waziristan forced Pakistan to be more cooperative in the war against terror. Mrs. Clinton, a New York Senator, started the controversy when she questioned Mr. Obama’s stand on foreign policy issues, particularly Pakistan, during a Wednesday night debate in Ohio. Mr. Obama, a freshman senator from Illinois and now a Democratic frontrunner in the 2008 Presidential race, maintained his tough stance, first revealed in an earlier debate, that if elected he will hunt down terror outfits, including in places like Pakistan. At the same time, Mr. Obama clarified that he never said he would “bomb” Pakistan but only act in the face of actionable intelligence about terrorist targets and if Islamabad is unable or unwilling to take action. Senator Clinton, who has sought to paint Mr Obama as too inexperienced to be the commander-in-chief of world’s only superpower, has questioned the wisdom of her rival’s threat to Pakistan at several recent debates.

Mrs. Clinton said that last summer, he basically threatened to bomb Pakistan, which I don’t think was a particularly wise position to take. She said that I have long advocated a much tougher approach to Musharraf and to Pakistan and have pushed the White House to do that. The former first lady argued that she has a wider breadth of foreign policy experience that makes her more qualified to face off against presumptive Republican nominee John McCain in the November 4 general election. Obama challenged her arguments, saying that she was building her case on wrong assumptions. He said that I never said I would bomb Pakistan. What I said was that if we have actionable intelligence against (Osama) bin Laden or other key Al Qaeda officials and Pakistan is unwilling or unable to strike against them, we should. And just several days ago, in fact, this administration did exactly that and took out the third-ranking Al Qaeda official (Abu Laith al-Libi),” he said, adding President Pervez Musharraf was now indicating that he would generally be “more cooperative in some of these efforts. He added that we don’t know how the new legislature in Pakistan will respond. But the fact is, it was the right strategy,

Back to top